Dressage and sport horse appraisals from a Grand Prix rider
Independent, well-documented horse valuations by ASEA Certified Equine Appraiser, USDF Gold Medalist and Grand Prix rider Melanie Montagano. Available nationwide.




When you need an appraisal
Choose your situation to learn more: dressage horses, insurance, charitable donations, or estates and divorce.
Insurance
Establish an accurate value for mortality, loss of use or major medical coverage.
Charitable donations
IRS-compliant reports for donated horses. The IRS requires a qualified appraisal for donations valued over $5,000.
Estates and succession
Valuations for estate planning, inheritance and probate.
Divorce and partnership disputes
Documented, defensible values when ownership has to be divided.
Litigation and claims
Support for claims involving injury, death, loss of use, misrepresentation or veterinary malpractice.
Buying or selling
An independent value to support a fair price.
Loans and collateral
Meet lender requirements when a horse secures financing.
Bankruptcy and liquidation
Fair market value for restructuring or asset sales.
Import and export
Documentation for customs declarations and international sales.
Appraisal reports and fees
Fees are for one horse. Each appraisal is confirmed in a written agreement before work begins.
Restricted Use
For the owner's own reference
- A concise report for limited distribution
- Best when a general market value is enough
- Not for insurance, IRS or legal use
Summary
Most requested
- Used for insurance and charitable donations
- Fully compliant with IRS requirements
- More detail than a Restricted Use report
- Not recommended where litigation is likely
Self Contained
For legal scrutiny
- A comprehensive, fully developed report
- Divorce, injury or liability claims, veterinary malpractice disputes
- Each additional horse: $750
- Expert witness and court time billed separately
Other fees
| Peer review A review of a report written by another appraiser | $200 |
|---|---|
| Retrospective appraisal A value as of a past date, such as for an insurance claim or an estate | $500 added to the report fee |
| Each additional horse, Self Contained report When more than one horse is appraised in a Self Contained report | $750 per horse |
Prices are in USD and are a general guide. Your written agreement confirms the final fee.
How an appraisal works
Tell us about the horse
Complete the quote request so Mel can build the horse's profile: pedigree, history, training and purpose.
Send the materials
Videos, clear photos, veterinary records, competition results and sales history. Mel does her appraisals remotely, so your horse never has to travel.
Market research
Mel compares similar horses and current market demand, weighing pedigree, age, training, show record and condition.
Your report
A 10 to 15 page report that documents and supports the horse's fair market value.


About the appraiser
Melanie Montagano holds a Bachelor's degree in Pre-Veterinary and Animal Biosciences from the University of Delaware and is certified by the American Society of Equine Appraisers.
She brings 25 years in the horse industry, more than 20 years of competition and 10 years of horse sales and importing to every report.
- USDF Bronze, Silver and Gold Medalist
- 2017 US Dressage Finals Open Grand Prix Champion
- Active USDF, USEF and FEI member
Independent by design
Mel does not appraise any horse she owns, is selling, or has any financial interest in. If a conflict exists, she will tell you and refer you to another certified appraiser.
Each valuation considers breed and bloodlines, age and condition, training level, show record, breeding potential, comparable sales and current market trends.
Appraisal questions
What is an equine appraisal, and why would I need one?
An appraisal is an independent, written opinion of what your horse is worth on a specific date, prepared by a certified appraiser to professional standards. Insurance companies, the IRS, estate attorneys and courts rely on it whenever money depends on a horse's value.
Owners usually need one when they insure a horse, donate a horse to a program, settle an estate, divide property in a divorce, or make a claim after a loss. Without a proper report, you are relying on a guess that may not hold up.
Which report do I need, and what does it cost?
- Restricted Use, $300. For your own reference, such as before you buy or sell.
- Summary, $400. The most requested report, accepted for insurance and charitable donations.
- Self Contained, $1,000. The most thorough report, for when the value may be challenged, such as in a divorce, a lawsuit or an insurance dispute.
Not sure which one fits? Describe your purpose on the quote form, and Mel will recommend the right report before you commit to anything.
Why choose Mel as your appraiser?
Mel is certified by the American Society of Equine Appraisers and prepares her reports to USPAP, the professional appraisal standards. Just as important, she brings more than 25 years of training horses from Training Level to Grand Prix, and she evaluates sale horses in the U.S. and Europe. She knows what horses actually sell for at every level.
She does not appraise any horse she has a financial interest in, so her opinion stays independent.
Does Mel need to see the horse in person?
No. Mel completes her appraisals remotely from current videos, photos and records, so she can appraise horses anywhere in the United States and your horse never has to travel.
How long does an appraisal take?
Most appraisals are finished within a few days to a week once Mel has all the materials. More complex reports can take longer. If you are working to a deadline, such as an insurance renewal, a donation date or a court date, say so in your request and Mel will tell you right away whether she can meet it.
Can you appraise a horse that has died or been sold?
Yes. A retrospective appraisal values a horse as of a past date. It is often needed for an insurance claim or an estate, and the sooner it is done, the easier it is to gather the records that support it.
Do you appraise horses outside dressage?
Yes. Dressage horses are Mel's specialty, and she appraises horses in all English and Western disciplines.
Work with Mel
More ways to be part of Mel's program.

Sponsor or own a horse
Join a syndicate, partner on a horse or sponsor Mel's season, and ride along on the road to international Grand Prix.
Partner With Mel
Train with Mel
Training and show coaching for Children, Juniors, Young Riders, U25 and adult amateurs, with Mel at the shows beside you. Clinics and virtual lessons too.
Train with Mel
Europe buying trips
Travel with Mel to Germany, the Netherlands and Belgium to find your next dressage horse, matched to your riding, goals and budget.
Plan a buying tripQuestions? Contact Mel or message her on WhatsApp at +1 (609) 602-6346.